Page 2 of 2

Re: Poll: Popular Gaming Scales

Posted: Wed Oct 05, 2016 12:15 pm
by shiftdel
Judging from my sales, 7000 is the most popular, it sells 4 times more than the second place, which is 1/3125 (not listed on your poll). I do not had requests for 1/3900, so, no models available on this scale from me yet. 1/5000 sold just once, as well as 1/4848.

Re: Poll: Popular Gaming Scales

Posted: Wed Oct 05, 2016 4:15 pm
by el gato
Savion wrote:I don't really have any other minis I would care to have - okay, except for a number of the Star Trek Attack Wing line, and those are kinda all over the place scale-wise, honestly. Not even sure what the scales of those are.
jkb-1 wrote:You might say the games are modeling something otber than the appearance and size of the ships; their power curves and combat effectiveness. As long as the Runabouts are smaller than the Galaxies, with room for the Mirandas in between them so there isn't such a psychological shock...
shiftdel wrote:Judging from my sales, 7000 is the most popular, it sells 4 times more than the second place, which is 1/3125 (not listed on your poll).
Thank you for your inputs. This is helpful. If I were to boil down your and others' answers, it seems like the size of the mini is more important than having a consistent scale. Would that be an accurate statement?

Re: Poll: Popular Gaming Scales

Posted: Fri Oct 07, 2016 3:47 am
by Savion
Fairly accurate. ;)

I do appreciate the constant scale of the SFB minis - well, almost constant scale... the best thing about this line is there is an upper limit to the size of how big a starship can get - in the SFB universe, anyway.

As far as Attack Wing goes... many of them are about or slightly larger than the SFB minis. It's more of the range of ships available within Attack Wing and that they can be gamed. It seems that like the SFB minis... there is an "upper limit" to the size that these game ships can be....! ;)

Since the TNG ships are all larger than the TOS/Movie eras, it does make sense to make those a smaller scale in order to preserve gaming space. Not everyone has a gym or park field to set up and play large-scale TNG miniatures, after all! It would seem that in this case... 1/7000 would be the best option for TNG era ST miniatures.

BTW, I didn't choose an option within the poll. It was too limited; I feel that 1/7000 is too small, IMO (except for noted above) for every case and era; but the only other larger option is the FASA scale? Sorry. It just seems odd to me that even after FASA folded decades ago with a now unsupported and largely abandoned gaming system that the only other contemporary ship miniature line to FASA that has been in constant production to now is completely overlooked by nearly everyone.

Re: Poll: Popular Gaming Scales

Posted: Fri Oct 07, 2016 2:48 pm
by el gato
Savion wrote:BTW, I didn't choose an option within the poll. It was too limited; I feel that 1/7000 is too small, IMO (except for noted above) for every case and era; but the only other larger option is the FASA scale? Sorry. It just seems odd to me that even after FASA folded decades ago with a now unsupported and largely abandoned gaming system that the only other contemporary ship miniature line to FASA that has been in constant production to now is completely overlooked by nearly everyone.
No need to apologize. After talking with you guys it's apparent to me that the poll was badly constructed. It should be about the preferred size of the minis vs. the scale of the minis.

So I suppose this begs the question: What would be the preferred size of a gaming ship, regardless of the era, race or game?

Re: Poll: Popular Gaming Scales

Posted: Sat Oct 08, 2016 10:40 pm
by Moongrim
Preferred size?
Just enough to occupy a hex without crowding out any other ships on adjacent hexes.

Re: Poll: Popular Gaming Scales

Posted: Tue Oct 11, 2016 4:49 pm
by el gato
Hmmm... not sure what that means. Is there a standard size for these hexes? How big are they?

Re: Poll: Popular Gaming Scales

Posted: Wed Oct 12, 2016 9:04 am
by Tesral
Attack wing annoys the heck out of me, Horribly out of scale to each other.

Re: Poll: Popular Gaming Scales

Posted: Thu Oct 13, 2016 1:13 am
by kobayashimaru
this was an interesting poll.
of those surveyed, 1:3900 seems the more popular.
How interesting.
I had anticipated 1:5000, 1:7000 and 1:8500 to be more selected options.
maybe even the odd 'troll' for other:1:2500 or something hehehe

1:15 000 or greater seems 'not at all popular'. :lol:

as for the rest, it's neck and neck,
very close race there.

Re: Poll: Popular Gaming Scales

Posted: Tue May 23, 2017 4:43 pm
by ecs05norway
I can't select an option in the poll, since my choice is 1/3125.